Catholic Answers Live
Catholic Answers
Categories: Religion & Spirituality
Listen to the last episode:
“What are Near Death Experiences?” This question opens a discussion on near-death experiences and the nature of the soul. The conversation also addresses critiques of NDE content, the concept of purification in the afterlife as described by Father Nathan Castle, and intriguing thoughts on the relationship between soul and brain in hypothetical scenarios. Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com Questions Covered: 00:55 – What do you say to critics of your content on NDEs, who say that it understates the skeptical research in the academic NDE literature? 18:50 – What do you think of the way purification seems to occur in Father Nathan Castle’s afterlife accounts? It would seem that rather than experiencing a “painful” and “fiery” purification as often depicted in pious stories and prayers about purgatory over the centuries, the souls essentially just learn new things and gradually correct their misunderstandings and errors, including needing to come to grips with their past sins and their effects on others. The idea that angels, saints and deceased relatives all get involved at different points along the journey of purification of souls and to help them move to a new level really appeals to me. 36:17 – If two individuals had their brains swapped, would their soul remain in their original bodies? Or if it stayed, how would the mismatched soul/brain experience consciousness? 46:01 – My wife is utterly convinced that all lizards including and especially the dinosaurs used to be dragons and wings were the limbs mentioned in Genesis when God punished the serpent. Note that most modern-day lizards although they do have legs still scurry around on their bellies because of their wide stance.
Previous episodes
-
6115 - #12720 What are Near Death Experiences? NDEs, Purgatory, and Souls - Jimmy Akin Sat, 16 May 2026
-
6114 - #12719 Can Humans Possess One Another? Purgatory and Ghosts - Jimmy Akin Fri, 15 May 2026
-
6113 - #12716 Can We Know God Is Personal Without Revelation? AMA: Dropped Calls - Joe Heschmeyer Thu, 14 May 2026
-
6112 - #12715 Why Is the Resurrection So Important? AMA: Dropped Calls - Joe Heschmeyer Wed, 13 May 2026
-
6111 - #12714 How Is the Eucharist Not Cannibalism? Holy Spirit and Sin - Karlo Broussard Wed, 13 May 2026
-
6110 - #12713 What’s Your Best Argument for Protestantism? - Karlo Broussard Tue, 12 May 2026
-
6109 - #12712 Every Orthodox Objection to Catholicism—Answered Part 2 - William Albrecht Tue, 12 May 2026
-
6108 - #12711 Every Orthodox Objection to Catholicism—Answered Part 1 - William Albrecht Mon, 11 May 2026
-
6107 - #12710 Was Jesus an Alien? Weird Questions - Jimmy Akin Sat, 09 May 2026
-
6106 - #12709 What Is the Devil’s Bible, Codex Gigas? Weird Questions - Jimmy Akin Fri, 08 May 2026
-
6105 - #12708 How Does the Church Investigate Marian Apparitions? AMA: Dropped Calls - Joe Heschmeyer Fri, 08 May 2026
-
6104 - #12707 How Do I Get Better at Debating Protestants? AMA: Dropped Calls - Joe Heschmeyer Thu, 07 May 2026
-
6103 - #12706 Is Leaving the Church Cause of Scandal a Mortal Sin? - Tom Nash Thu, 07 May 2026
-
6102 - #12705 What Do Modern People Not Get About Jesus? Mary and Divinity - Marcellino D'Ambrosio Wed, 06 May 2026
-
6101 - #12704 Why Do Catholics Believe in Baptism? Infant Baptism and More - Karlo Broussard Wed, 06 May 2026
-
6100 - #12703 Why Do Catholics Believe in Marys Virginity? Pope and Saints - Karlo Broussard Tue, 05 May 2026
-
6099 - #12702 What Does It Mean That Marriage Is Sacred? Healing and Virtue - Gregory Popcak Tue, 05 May 2026
-
6098 - #12701 What Is the Most Beautiful Aspect of Catholic Faith? Mass and Relationship - Adrian Lawson Mon, 04 May 2026
-
6097 - #12700 How Can Couples Decide When They Disagree? Prayer and Unity - Jimmy Akin Sat, 02 May 2026
-
6096 - #12699 If Jesus Was Jewish, Why Are We Christian? Annulments, Yoga - Jimmy Akin Fri, 01 May 2026
-
6095 - #12698 What Would It Take for Catholics and Orthodox to Reunite? Marriage Validity and Confession - Tim Staples Fri, 01 May 2026
-
6094 - #12697 Did Mary and Joseph Doubt Jesus? Prayer, Divorce, and Faith - William Albrecht Thu, 30 Apr 2026
-
6093 - #12696 Who Was the First Catholic? Animals, Souls, and St. Paul - Joe Heschmeyer Thu, 30 Apr 2026
-
6092 - #12695 Do Catholics and Mormons Worship the Same God? Doctrine, Faith - Joe Heschmeyer Wed, 29 Apr 2026
-
6091 - #12694 What Can Angels Do for Us? Guardian Angels and Grace - Fr. Mike Driscoll Wed, 29 Apr 2026
-
6090 - #12693 Can We Have Assurance of Salvation? Apologetics and Evangelism - John Martignoni Tue, 28 Apr 2026
-
6089 - #12692 How Is the Mass a Sacrifice? Intinction and Etiquette - Tom Nash Tue, 28 Apr 2026
-
6088 - #12691 How Do You Reach Young People Online and Teach Faith? Mon, 27 Apr 2026
-
6087 - #12690 Aborted Babies Are Not Doomed to Hell – Scripture and Authority - Jimmy Akin Sat, 25 Apr 2026
-
6086 - #12689 How Can I Help My Friend Consider Catholicism? Women and the Church - Jimmy Akin Fri, 24 Apr 2026
-
6085 - #12688 How Do I Witness to Others? No Marriage in Heaven - Karlo Broussard Fri, 24 Apr 2026
-
6084 - #12687 Is Infant Baptism Necessary? Meat, Judas, and Sin Explained - Karlo Broussard Thu, 23 Apr 2026
-
6083 - #12686 What Is the Gift of Tongues? Polygamy and Zechariahs - Joe Heschmeyer Thu, 23 Apr 2026
-
6082 - #12685 What’s a One-Minute Defense for the Papacy? - Joe Heschmeyer Wed, 22 Apr 2026
-
6081 - #12684 Are There Doctrinal Differences on the Septuagint? AI, Visions - Jimmy Akin Wed, 22 Apr 2026
-
6080 - #12683 Do Dinosaurs Create Issues for Catholic Beliefs and Faith? - Jimmy Akin Tue, 21 Apr 2026
-
6079 - #12682 What Verses Prove Peter Was the Pope? Authority and Tradition - Ben Bollinger Tue, 21 Apr 2026
-
6078 - #12681 Does Anxiety Mean Im a Bad Christian? Trust and Healing - Gregory Popcak Mon, 20 Apr 2026
-
6077 - #12680 Did God Harden Pharaohs Heart? Cattle, Myrrh, and Heaven - Jimmy Akin Sat, 18 Apr 2026
-
6076 - #12679 Why Did God Call the Hebrews to Slaughter Canaanites? Judgment and Love - Jimmy Akin Fri, 17 Apr 2026
-
6075 - #12678 Do Catholics Treat Mary Like a God? Gospel of John, New Eve - Trent Horn Fri, 17 Apr 2026
-
6074 - #12677 What Convinced Tim to Leave Evangelicalism? Penance, Eucharist - Tim Staples Thu, 16 Apr 2026
-
6073 - #12676 Is Being Unmarried a Call to Priesthood? Rosary, Purgatory - Joe Heschmeyer Thu, 16 Apr 2026
-
6072 - #12675 Are Catholics Modern-Day Pharisees? Eucharist and Grace - Joe Heschmeyer Wed, 15 Apr 2026
-
6071 - #12674 What are the Parameters for Papal Infallibility? Mary and Saints - Karlo Broussard Wed, 15 Apr 2026
-
6070 - #12673 Is the Assumption of Mary in Scripture? Eucharist, Priests - Karlo Broussard Tue, 14 Apr 2026
-
6069 - #12672 Do Catholics Really Eat God? Vatican II and Mass Changes - Tom Nash Tue, 14 Apr 2026
-
6068 - #12671 How Can I Heal a Strained Relationship? Forgiveness and Love - Rose Sweet Mon, 13 Apr 2026
-
6067 - #12670 AMA: Catholicism - Joe Heschmeyer Sat, 11 Apr 2026
-
6066 - #12669 AMA: Catholicism - Joe Heschmeyer Fri, 10 Apr 2026