GoLoud|122 - Brian Murphy: What Happened Outside Club Anabel?
With an avid interest in true crime I want to share the stories from my home country of Ireland with you. Let's visit the darker side of the Emerald Isle together.
This episode details the tragic death of 18-year-old Brian Murphy following a violent assault outside Club Annabelle in Dublin in August 2000. It examines the events of the night, witness accounts, and medical findings that confirmed the death was a deliberate assault rather than an accident.
The narrative explores the complex legal aftermath, including the initial trials, the difficulty of proving manslaughter due to unidentified fatal blows, and the subsequent collapse of the manslaughter retrial. The episode also addresses the tension between legal requirements for proof and public perceptions regarding class privilege and the human cost of the legal process.
Chapters
Click on a chapter to go directly to that moment
Highlights
The Court of Criminal Appeal would later put the main part of the attack as somewhere between 15 and 30 seconds.
00:01:40 · This highlights the extremely brief duration of the fatal violence inflicted upon Brian.
He described evidence of considerable violence and said the injuries weren't consistent with Brian simply falling and striking his head off the ground.
00:13:18 · The state pathologist's findings confirm that the death was the result of a deliberate assault rather than an accident.
So, from the beginning, Gardie knew Brian had been subjected to a serious group assault. What they didn't know was which injury had caused his death or who had inflicted it.
00:14:34 · The narrator establishes the central difficulty faced by investigators in identifying the specific perpetrator and cause of death.
At one point she asked, where is my baby in all of this?
00:24:32 · This quote from Brian's mother illustrates the dehumanizing effect the legal process had on the victim's identity.
a nine-person jury returned a unanimous verdict that Brian had been unlawfully killed.
00:34:28 · This marks the significant outcome of the coroner's inquest regarding the nature of Brian's death.
This episode details the tragic death of 18-year-old Brian Murphy following a violent assault outside Club Annabelle in Dublin in August 2000. It examines the events of the night, witness accounts, and medical findings that confirmed the death was a deliberate assault rather than an accident.
The narrative explores the complex legal aftermath, including the initial trials, the difficulty of proving manslaughter due to unidentified fatal blows, and the subsequent collapse of the manslaughter retrial. The episode also addresses the tension between legal requirements for proof and public perceptions regarding class privilege and the human cost of the legal process.
Published13 Sep 2026
Duration42:59
Episodes
122-
Brian Murphy: What Happened Outside Club Anabel?
Listened
This episode details the tragic death of 18-year-old Brian Murphy following a violent assault outside Club Annabelle in Dublin in August 2000. It examines the events of the night, witness accounts, and medical findings that confirmed the death was a deliberate assault rather than an accident.
The narrative explores the complex legal aftermath, including the initial trials, the difficulty of proving manslaughter due to unidentified fatal blows, and the subsequent collapse of the manslaughter retrial. The episode also addresses the tension between legal requirements for proof and public perceptions regarding class privilege and the human cost of the legal process.
13 Sep 2026
121-
The Last Fare: Eileen Costello O’Shaughnessy
Listened
This episode explores the 1997 murder of taxi driver Eileen Costello O'Shocknessy, tracing the events from her final shift to the discovery of her body at Tinker's Lane. The investigation examines mysterious sightings of her taxi involving unidentified passengers and a bearded driver, alongside the forensic challenges faced by investigators.
The narrative details the scrutiny of potential suspect Thomas Murray and the subsequent decades of failed public appeals. Despite the unveiling of a memorial plaque in 2022 and ongoing efforts by her family to find justice, the case remains an active investigation without a conviction.
06 Sep 2026
120-
Days from Home: Orla Benson
Listened
This episode explores the tragic 1995 murder of Orla Benson in Boston and the subsequent investigation that led to the conviction of Pedro Rosario. The narrative details the forensic evidence used in the trial, including DNA and bite mark analysis, as well as the systemic failures in Boston's hiring processes that allowed a man with a violent criminal history to be employed by the city.
The episode further examines the legal battles following the verdict, including Rosario's appeals regarding inadmissible hearsay and prosecutorial conduct. Finally, it reflects on the lasting legacy of Orla Benson through the scholarships and memorials established by her family to honor her vibrant life and ensure her name is remembered beyond the tragedy.
30 Aug 2026
119-
93 Injuries: What Happened to Kelly Lynch?
Listened
This episode explores the tragic death of 23-year-old Kelly Marie Lynch, whose body was discovered in the Ulster Canal in Monaghan. While initial official theories suggested an accidental drowning, the investigation is marked by significant discrepancies, including the discovery of 93 separate injuries on her body and concerns regarding the mishandling of the crime scene and evidence.
The narrative follows the Lynch family's fight for accountability as they navigate conflicting medical opinions, delayed CCTV retrieval, and potential forensic contamination. The episode details their advocacy for systemic change through the 'Kelly Protocol' and their ongoing efforts to ensure transparency in investigations involving unexplained deaths.
23 Aug 2026
118-
Poisoning at Shandy Hall
Listened
This episode explores the Coachford poisoning case, beginning with the 1887 death of Mary Laura Cross and the subsequent suspicion cast upon her husband, Dr. Philip Henry Eustace Cross. Following an exhumation that revealed arsenic and strychnine in her body, investigators examined Dr. Cross's access to poisons and his relationship with a former governess.
The prosecution presented evidence of arsenic purchases and eyewitness accounts of Mary Laura's physical decline, leading to a dramatic battle of medical opinions regarding the cause of death. The trial concluded with a guilty verdict and the execution of Dr. Cross, leaving behind a lasting historical legacy and legal controversy surrounding the coroner's inquest.
16 Aug 2026
117-
Noah Donohoe: The Inquest
Listened
This episode examines the inquest into the death of 14-year-old Noah Donoghue, detailing his final movements through Belfast and the evidence presented regarding his character and state of mind. The investigation covers witness accounts of his disappearance, the discovery of his body in a storm drain, and forensic findings that identified drowning as the cause of death.
The inquest further explores toxicology reports, the memorialization of his Instagram account, and critical failures in CCTV collection by investigators. The proceedings conclude with the theft of Noah's belongings and a jury unable to reach a unanimous verdict, leaving the inquest adjourned.
09 Aug 2026
116-
The Vanishing Point: Ciara Glennon
Listened
This episode explores the disappearance and murder of Ciara Glennon in Perth, Australia, and the decades-long investigation that followed. Amidst a climate of fear known as Operation Marco, authorities investigated the possibility of a serial killer operating in the Claremont area.
Through advancements in DNA technology, specifically low copy number testing, investigators eventually linked a series of crimes spanning twenty years to Bradley Robert Edwards. The episode covers the trial and conviction of Edwards, as well as the enduring legacy and resilience of the Glennon family.
02 Aug 2026
115-
Murder Born of Delusion?
Listened
This episode explores a historical true crime case from 1846 in Martinstown, County Limerick, during the height of the Great Famine. It details the brutal murders of Anne O'Grady and her servant Ellen Walsh by John O'Grady, driven by what medical experts believed were fixed delusions.
The narrative follows the aftermath of the killings, covering the subsequent legal battles and the application of the McNaughton Rules. While medical experts argued O'Grady's symptoms were a calculated performance to avoid execution, his death sentence was eventually commuted to life transportation. The episode concludes by reflecting on how historical records preserve the details of the killer while the voices of the victims have been lost to time.
26 Jul 2026
114-
The Case That Still Won't Close: Philomena Gillane
Listened
19 Jul 2026
113-
Fatal Desperation: Helen O’Reilly’s Story
Listened
12 Jul 2026
112-
The Quarry
Listened
05 Jul 2026
111-
The Stranger in the Ford: Una Lynskys Story
Listened
28 Jun 2026
110-
Digital Deception: Natalie McNally
Listened
21 Jun 2026
109-
Ireland Crimes And Mysteries Recommends: GoLoud Sleep Sounds
Listened
16 Jun 2026
108-
I'll See You Later, Mr Moonlight (Part 2)
Listened
14 Jun 2026
107-
I'll See You Later, Mr Moonlight (Part 1)
Listened
07 Jun 2026
106-
What would I do without you? Nadine Lott
Listened
31 May 2026
105-
A Life full of Promise:Nicola Furlong
Listened
24 May 2026
104-
Marlhill: Two Shots, One Frame (Part Two)
Listened
17 May 2026
103-
Marlhill: Two Shots, One Frame (Part One)
Listened
10 May 2026
102-
Marilyn Rynn, A DNA Legacy
Listened
03 May 2026
101-
Nules recommends - A New Day with Gerry Hussey
Listened
30 Apr 2026
99-
The Last Walk Home, Liam Farrell
Listened
19 Apr 2026
98-
The Unforgotten, The Missing That Don't Make the Headlines
Listened
12 Apr 2026
97-
A House Full of Victims, The McElhill Family
Listened
05 Apr 2026
96-
Murder Most Macabre, Shaun Duffy
Listened
29 Mar 2026
95-
The Night the Music Stopped, Lorcan O'Byrnes Story
Listened
22 Mar 2026
94-
Zoe & Ella, A Mother's Mission
Listened
15 Mar 2026
93-
Grave Error, Tina Satchwell
Listened
08 Mar 2026
92-
Stolen Dreams, Sheola Keaney
Listened
01 Mar 2026
91-
Unfinished Journey, Bernadette Connolly
Listened
22 Feb 2026
90-
Final Betrayal, Siobhán McLaughlin
Listened
15 Feb 2026
89-
Frozen Grief, The Sad Case of Annie McCarrick
Listened
08 Feb 2026
88-
Vanished in the Night, Sandra Collins
Listened
01 Feb 2026
87-
Hiding in Plain Sight, Ann Lovett
Listened
25 Jan 2026
86-
A Nuns Journey, Sr Philomena Lyons
Listened
18 Jan 2026
85-
Discussing Antoinette Smith with Ciaran McConnell
Listened
11 Jan 2026
84-
Gina Kerry Speaks: Imelda Keenan
Listened
04 Jan 2026
83-
Damien Hipwell Speaks: 10 Years Without Dean Roche
Listened
28 Dec 2025
82-
A journey to Justice, Phyllis Murphy
Listened
21 Dec 2025
81-
A Life Cut Short: Ana Kriégal
Listened
14 Dec 2025
80-
The Tragic Tale of Colleen Bawn
Listened
07 Dec 2025
79-
One Night in Bunratty: Patrick Nugent
Listened
30 Nov 2025
78-
An Interview with Detective John Sweetman
Listened
23 Nov 2025
77-
The Walk Home, Jill Meagher
Listened
16 Nov 2025
76-
Broken Skies: Tuskar Rock
Listened
09 Nov 2025
75-
Introducing Lines of Enquiry: The Hidden Stories Behind Ireland’s Most Compelling Cases