Serialously with Annie Elise

Serialously with Annie Elise

Serialously is hosted by Annie Elise, best known for her true-crime YouTube channel “10 to Life” with over 1.5M subscribers.  Annie created Serialously after decades of listening to true crime and craving more than just the headlines; she wanted all the overlooked details everyone else seemed to miss. Here, you’ll find everything you’d normally end up Googling yourself - the timelines, the red flags, the social media history, and everything in between. Even better, you’ll hear the story the way you’d want to: like your best friend is filling you in. Annie covers cases in an engaging, conversational way with every detail sleuthed out.  Whether it’s breaking true crime news, viral cases, or ongoing trials, Serialously keeps you in the loop in real time - just like having a conversation with your best friend, or hopefully your new true crime bestie! If you've been looking for someone to chat all things true crime with you and a community that’s just as curious as you are - welcome, we're happy you're here! xx *This podcast is not affiliated with The New York Times.
00:00
00:00

Episode's summary

Makayla Settles moved across the country at 18 to finally build a relationship with her biological father. But just two days after arriving in California, he brutally assaulted her. Five months later, Makayla took her own life, and after pleading guilty to incest, her father was sentenced to just one year in county jail. Now, after serving less than six months, he’s walked free, leaving her family demanding answers about how this could possibly be justice.

Episodes

513-

459: 4 Hour Assault By Her Own Father Results in Her Death | Makayla Settles

Makayla Settles moved across the country at 18 to finally build a relationship with her biological father. But just two days after arriving in California, he brutally assaulted her. Five months later, Makayla took her own life, and after pleading guilty to incest, her father was sentenced to just one year in county jail. Now, after serving less than six months, he’s walked free, leaving her family demanding answers about how this could possibly be justice.

16 Nov 2026
512-

458: Baby Survives Being Buried Alive, Obsessed Stepdad’s Shrine of Underwear & Incest Dad Walks Free

Join Annie as she breaks down what’s happening in true crime this week.

12 Nov 2026
511-

457: He Groomed Her For Years: 40K Texts, Wiped Phones & His Brother Sleeping with Her | Sandra Birchmore

For years, Sandra Birchmore’s death was ruled a suicide, despite the disturbing questions surrounding her relationship with a Stoughton police officer who had known her since she was just 12 years old. Now, Matthew Farwell is on trial for allegedly grooming Sandra as a teenager, killing her while she was pregnant, and staging the scene to cover it up. But now, 50 witnesses take the stand, thousands of messages are examined, and one shocking DNA revelation turns the case upside down.

Mon, 9 Nov 2026 08:00:00 +0000
510-

456: Reddit Hired Attack, 281 Arrests in Florida, Husband Kills Wife’s Lover With His Kids in The Bed

Join Annie as she breaks down what’s happening in true crime this week.

Thu, 5 Nov 2026 08:00:00 +0000
509-

455: She Beheaded Her Ex…And Married His Son | The Johnathan Willette Case

In 2023, Johnathan Willette was found brutally murdered inside his Henderson home, but what investigators discovered at the scene was only the beginning of this bizarre case. Johnathan had been decapitated, his head was nowhere to be found, and investigators couldn’t figure out how someone could have carried out the crime without anyone hearing or seeing them. As detectives dug into his final hours, they uncovered an incredibly complicated family dynamic and a timeline that didn’t seem to add up.

Mon, 2 Nov 2026 08:00:00 +0000